The immaturity shown by the Indian defense is highly questionable. That raises many doubts about their readiness for a sudden terrorist attacks of this nature. However India had his long wind habit of pressurize/ advice Sri Lanka about how to deal with terror.
This is a simple comparison that I have done in between Indian Army against a terrorist group and Sri Lankan Army against the most ruthless terrorist group.
You will have the Indian army in the left side while Sri Lankan Army is in the right side..
India | Vs | Sri Lanka |
 | <--> |  |
Peeping vs Aiming | ||
 | <--> |  |
Waiting vs Exploring/ Chasing | ||
.jpg) | <--> |  |
Standing/ Relaxing vs Expecting/ Vigilent | ||
 | <--> |  |
Defending vs Attacking | ||
 | <--> |  |
Searching vs Petroling | ||
 | <--> |  |
Hiding/ Aiming vs Aiming/ Attacking | ||
.jpg) | <--> |  |
Looking vs Finding | ||
.jpg) | <--> |  |
Women Soldier | ||
 | <--> | .jpg) |
Commando | ||
 | <--> |  |
Hiding vs Attacking | ||
I am by no mean expecting you to come to any conclusions by looking at this.. However Sri Lanka will not hesitate to provide military aids if India is willing to ask for it..
23 comments:
India Sucks big time. Great article ayya. Way to go
Nirosh, Good job machan.. I like this. Keep it up.
:)
Good article. Can't stop laughing.
We sri lankans find it laughable, but it is the truth.
I followed this incident in order to find out, what I can learn from the "most feared" black cat commandos in the "super power" nation in the south asian region. But it was disturbing to see, how they reacted to this situation. I purposely forget the indian police because it is not worth mentioning their role.
Some thoughts on the incident:
1. Time frame:
It took about 12 hours for the black cats to be deployed. A professional commando entity should be made deployable within one hour of any incident.
2. No plan :
The most disturbing thing was that the "black cats" began attacking the attackers directly, obviously without a plan. Although, well trained, well equipped and well informed, the attackers are in a hostile region when they carry out the attack. Therefore the commandos always have the advantage. They should execute a combing operation with utmost care, beginning from a well secured side, where the hostages can move out quickly. They must first let the attackers feel, that they are not confronted directly, because the attackers will kill as many hostages as they can to cause the maximum destruction when they get to know that the counter-attack takes place. The plan would be to attack all the besieged sites simultaneously to get the attackers by surprise.
3. The face of the soldiers:
More than any thing, what is most disturbing is the "men behind the weapon". When I see the black cat commandos signaling victory signs or laughing to get a photo shoot, I am not surprised that they get the job "done" in 60 hours. When I see the pictures now, I am so happy that indian prime minister was safe in Sri Lanka during the SAARC summit with these people around them.
My conclusion:
1. Black cats are not worthy enough to get the most feared color in the world. So better it would be something like pink or red.
2. Cats are predators who attack their prey thereby not letting them to be a prey of another predator. The rat is such an animal who always fall as a prey to others.
P.S. "The noble emperor in Sri lanka"
Whether the legend is true or not, that is the best attitude a sri lankan can have. And the attitude is everything.
Keep up the good work man.
Great comparison..
Even though, we don't expect to cheer the wanton situation of India, it is good that they experience their own game by means!
Nice comparison... way to go pal...
Now their mouths are shut, not to open for a long time...
Great Comparison and Good comment by commando.......
Good comparison in terms of the military tactics and the superiority.
Why don't we discuss about the aftermath of the incident?
Dozens of their superiors resigned from their portfolios. It included the advisor to the National Security and the Home Minister.
Will this happen in Sri Lanka?
Is there anyone to take the responsibility and step down?
Thats the sad part.
Its true that our soldiers are somewhat close to Killinochchi and you guys are talking about the military superiority and the tactics over here. But no one is declaring the actual scores.
So the point is, we can not place our guys top of another.
But keep it in mind that we are fighting against a guerrilla gang.
See what has happened in Iraq and Afghanistan, most powerful armies fought hard to gain the control over the land but still we are seeing death tolls in double digits.
This is not to let you guys down. We need a good tactic in this kind of war. Battles in mass scale won't give the ultimate solution.
I do appreciate, if there is a defense analyst to suggest LRRP type of operations rather than wasting of millions of dollars worth warfare and the lives of soldiers.
Such a tactic will bring down the TAF and the LTTE leadership. Thats the only way to confront against these kinds of notorious terrorists.
Else we are giving unwanted publicity for them throughout the globe.
I think this kind of jokes are not possible to us, Coz. this makes some bad things to nations.
har,
Why do you think that this is a joke, I don't see any jokes here..
Har,
/*
I think this kind of jokes are not possible to us
*/
This is not a joke, but some time the TRUTH make you laugh. I cannot help .. Anyway I ecourage you to look around, may be you can start reading the comment posted by Commando here, then go to defencewire blog and read it. That will help you understand how poor the India Black Cats were..
/*
this makes some bad things to nations.
*/
Buddy, if you are serious, then talk to Ranil first and then to Mangala about the bad thing that they do to the nation, then come here.. We can talk how this post going to effect the nation badly
This is cool. India can now take back all the advice given to us on dealing with terrorism. Nice comparison bro.
This is 100% true. hats off for SL Forces. Keep up the good work guys ....
HELL Vs. HEAVEN
Gud Work.
Regards !
- Uditha
We make war that we may live in peace.
nimanthi
“In the name of the best within you, do not sacrifice this world to those who are its worst. In the name of the values that keep you alive, do not let your vision of man be distorted by the ugly, the cowardly, the mindless in those who have never achieved his title. Do not lose your knowledge that man's proper estate is an upright posture, an intransigent mind and a step that travels unlimited roads. Do not let your fire go out, spark by irreplaceable spark, in the hopeless swamps of the approximate, the not-quite, the not-yet, the not-at-all. Do not let the hero in your soul perish, in lonely frustration for the life you deserved, but have never been able to reach. Check your road and the nature of your battle. The world you desired can be won, it exists, it is real, it is possible, it's yours.”
We make war that we may live in peace.
Reply:
Bulshit!!!! That's what Stupid Bush Says and Kill so many Innocent people..
In the annals of modern warfare, the 1971 war between India and Pakistan is regarded as a template of brilliance. Within 13 days, the Indian army routed Pakistan in one of the swiftest campaigns of the 20th century.
http://www.militaryphotos.net/forums/showthread.php?t=98280&page=7
* Indian Side 120 soldiers 4-8 RCL gun mounted on jeeps ,5-10 Hunters,many anti-tank mine but not deployed sate.
* Pakistani side -4000+ soldiers , 100-110 Patton Tanks (some chinese Too),Air support
Result- 40-60 Paki tanks destroyed completly,20 return to base in damaged conditions Captured-20-40,2000-3000 Paki soldier killed unknown captured.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Longewala
Search Longewala on google images & it will you all destoyed tank
This battle is also known as "Battle of Longewala" or "SAGA OF LONGEWALA"
what was the biggest Militry Surrender??
It was Poor Pak army 93000 soldiers surrender in Front of brave Indian Army
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrument_of_Surrender_(1971)
Any thing else
But Finally I can Say Sri Lanka Special Force is better Than Indian Black Cats
--Real Indian --
What a Great Idea!
තුන් හෙළේ කැලෑ තුල සිංහ පැටව්, නැත උන් රට අතැර ගොසින්...!
Viran..............
with all do fairness....ur comparison is based on better pictures
Though its pictures they say the reality :D
viran {
ජාතිය රන් විමනක් වේ... ආගම මිණි පහනක් වේ... ...............//
}
hahahahahahha...
You people have made my day.Such a bunch of immatures.
You lost 30% of your country to a terrorist organization and took 30 years to finish them off and you laugh at India??
Worse still,you needed the entire world including India,China,Russia,US,Pakistan on your side to finish off a terrorist organisation which was on its own and led by a 8th standard dropout and you guys have the audacity to laugh at India.
You guys are Such a bunch of half baked nuts
Post a Comment